Meta description: Stretch film and shrink film both unitize a pallet, but equipment, energy, throughput and cost per pallet differ. Compare both methods before you buy.
Stretch film holds a pallet together through elastic tension. Shrink film holds it through heat. Both unitize a load, yet they differ in equipment, energy, cycle time and cost per pallet far more than they differ in price per kilogram. This guide compares the two containment methods on the points that decide a purchase, then sets out which loads suit each one.
Table of Contents
- How Each Method Contains a Load
- Equipment, Energy and Throughput
- Cost per Pallet, Not Cost per Kilogram
- Where Each Method Fits
- Specification Points That Decide Performance
- Common Buying Mistakes
- How to Evaluate a Supplier
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Source Containment Film from Pefilmpack
How Each Method Contains a Load
PE stretch film is applied under tension. The film is elongated during wrapping, and its elastic recovery pulls back against the load, generating a hoop force that holds cartons, bags and cases against each other. Containment force is adjustable layer by layer and relaxes gradually after application.
Shrink film works differently. It is applied loosely, then heated above its orientation release temperature. The film contracts and locks into a skin that follows the shape of the load. Once cooled, the wrap is dimensionally set: it does not relax back the way a stretched film does.
The practical consequences are consistent. Stretch film is re-tensionable and removable in seconds, and it leaves the corners of a load partly open, so moisture can escape. Shrink film gives a continuous sealed surface, which resists rain, dust and tampering, but it cannot be adjusted after shrinking and it needs venting on loads that contain moisture.
Equipment, Energy and Throughput
The capital and operating profile of the two methods is the single largest difference in a business case. Stretch wrapping needs a mechanical machine and electricity for motors. Shrink wrapping needs a heat source, and heat is the dominant operating cost.
| Factor | Stretch film | Shrink film |
|---|---|---|
| Core equipment | Turntable, rotary arm or hand wrap | Shrink tunnel, hood shrink frame or hand heat gun |
| Energy input | Motors and controls only | Gas or electric heat, continuous when in production |
| Heat-up time | None | Minutes at shift start; tunnel recovery between cycles |
| Cycle time | Commonly 30–90 seconds per pallet on automatic machines | Typically longer, set by dwell time in the heat zone |
| Floor space | Compact; machine footprint plus fork access | Machine plus tunnel plus cool-down run-out |
| Ventilation | Not required | Required for combustion by-products and heat load |
| Changeover | Roll change in under two minutes | Film or hood change, plus temperature re-stabilization |
A shrink line also needs a cool-down distance before pallets are stacked or moved, otherwise the wrap deforms. That distance is often the constraint that decides whether an existing bay can take a shrink system at all.
Cost per Pallet, Not Cost per Kilogram
Film price per kilogram is the least useful number in this comparison. The decision metric is cost per pallet wrapped, built from four components:
- Film mass per pallet in grams, at the gauge and wrap pattern actually used.
- Film price converted to cost per gram, after pre-stretch ratio is applied.
- Energy consumed per pallet, which is negligible for stretch and material for shrink.
- Labor and downtime per pallet, including roll changes and rejected wraps.
As an illustration only, using assumptions a buyer should replace with local figures: a machine-wrapped pallet consuming 180 g of film at USD 1.70 per kilogram carries about USD 0.31 of film. A shrink hood consuming 300 g at USD 1.80 per kilogram carries about USD 0.54 of film, before heat. If heat adds USD 0.25–0.60 per pallet depending on fuel and tunnel efficiency, the shrink option lands at roughly two to three times the stretch cost per pallet. That gap is why shrink is bought for protection, not for economy.
The same arithmetic runs the other way in some operations. Where a shrink tunnel is already installed and running at capacity, the marginal cost of heat per pallet falls, and the film saving from eliminating stretch wrap and its edge protection can offset the energy.
Where Each Method Fits
Loads that suit stretch film
- Mixed SKUs and changing pallet heights on the same line.
- High-throughput distribution centers where cycle time rules.
- Loads that need partial ventilation, such as produce or freshly filled containers.
- Returns and reverse logistics, where film must come off quickly and cleanly.
- Operations that want a single-material, mono-PE waste stream.
Loads that suit shrink film
- Outdoor or yard storage, where rain and UV exposure are routine.
- Long-term storage where dust ingress is a quality issue.
- Loads needing tamper evidence, such as high-value consumer goods.
- Uniform, box-shaped loads that shrink evenly without bridging.
- Export shipments in humid climates where a sealed skin prevents condensation damage.
Neither method rescues a badly built pallet. If the stacking pattern is unstable, the fix is the wrapping pattern, not a thicker film.
Specification Points That Decide Performance
Most containment failures trace back to a specification that was left vague at quotation stage. Fix these in writing.
- Gauge. Machine stretch film is commonly supplied in the 12–23 micron range for general loads, with heavier gauges for sharp or heavy goods. Pallet shrink covers are normally supplied thicker, since they must carry their own weight during shrinkage.
- Width. 500 mm is the common machine width; 750 mm and wider appear on large-format turntables and hood applications.
- Core. 76 mm (3 inch) for machine rolls, 50 mm (2 inch) for hand rolls.
- Stretch or shrink behavior. For stretch film, ask for elongation at break and the recommended pre-stretch ratio. For shrink film, ask for MD and TD free shrink, measured under ASTM D2732, and the shrink temperature window.
- Tack. One-sided cling keeps rolls from blocking on the roll; two-sided cling adds load-to-load adhesion. State which you need.
- UV and color. Outdoor storage requires a UV-stabilized grade; opaque colors block light but also hide load labels.
Requirements may vary by application, market and applicable standard, so confirm the test method and the acceptance range with your supplier rather than accepting a generic datasheet.
Common Buying Mistakes
- Comparing film price per kilogram. A cheaper film at a lower pre-stretch ratio can cost more per pallet than a dearer film that stretches further.
- Downgauging to save grams. Thin film that punctures at the corner costs more in rework than the resin saved.
- Leaving energy out of the shrink case. Heat is a recurring cost, not a one-off installation item.
- Specifying shrink for mixed pallet heights. Uniform shrink needs uniform geometry; irregular loads bridge and tear.
- Ignoring removal at destination. A sealed skin that takes ten minutes to cut off is a hidden labor cost for the receiver.
- Ordering a container before a trial. One pallet wrapped on your own machine settles more questions than three rounds of email.
How to Evaluate a Supplier
- Ask for the gauge tolerance, not just the nominal gauge. A ±10% band on a 17 micron film is a different product from ±5%.
- Request lot-to-lot consistency data on thickness, tack and color, since containment force drifts with gauge.
- Confirm the supplier can quote both PE shrink film and stretch film, so the comparison is made on one set of commercial terms.
- Check whether pre-stretch is a film property or a machine setting, and who takes responsibility for the yield claim.
- Ask how rolls are packed for sea freight: suspended, palletized, or floor-loaded with edge protection.
- Confirm lead time against your peak season, not against the sample order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use stretch film and shrink film on the same pallet?
Yes, and it is common on export loads. A stretch base wrap stabilizes the load, and a shrink hood or top sheet provides weather protection. The two layers must be specified together so the film thicknesses are not double-counted in the cost model.
Which method is faster per pallet?
Stretch wrapping is normally faster. A rotary arm or high-speed turntable can complete a pallet in under a minute, while shrink cycles are bounded by heat dwell and cool-down. Throughput requirements usually decide the method before film cost does.
Does shrink film hold an unstable load better?
Not necessarily. Shrink film follows the shape of the load and adds little compressive force, so a leaning or settling load can still shift inside the skin. Stretch film with controlled containment force and a top platen is usually the better answer for unstable loads.
Is stretch film or shrink film better for outdoor storage?
Shrink film, if the grade is UV stabilized. Standard stretch film degrades under prolonged UV exposure and its tack layer collects dust. For short-term yard storage, an opaque UV-stabilized stretch film with a top cover is a workable compromise.
What thickness should I specify for each?
For machine stretch film, 15–20 micron covers most general export loads, with 20–23 micron for heavy or sharp-edged goods. Shrink covers are normally thicker because the film must remain intact while contracting. Both figures are starting points, not standards.
Can both films be recycled together?
Only if both are polyethylene and are collected as one stream. POF shrink film is a different polymer structure and contaminates a PE stream, so keep the two separated at the baler.
Source Containment Film from Pefilmpack
Weishan Litong Packing Material Co., Ltd. manufactures PE stretch film, PE shrink film and POF heat shrink film for importers, distributors and export packers. Roll width, thickness, wound length, roll weight, color and core size are made to order, in hand-grade and machine-grade specifications, with OEM branding and printed cartons available. Because the same factory supplies both containment methods, buyers can compare options on consistent commercial terms instead of reconciling two suppliers’ quotations. Export packing is configured for sea freight, and specifications can be matched to your existing wrapper or shrink tunnel rather than the other way round.
Send your product type, pallet dimensions, load weight, current film specification and destination port for a quotation. If you are still deciding between the two methods, describe the load and the storage conditions, and we will quote both so the comparison is like for like.